Buffalo Bills special teams watched Ray Davis reach the 46-yard line, then sent Josh Allen onto the field at the 17. A holding penalty had swallowed the difference. With halftime approaching in Buffalo’s September 13, 2026, season opener against Houston, a promising return became a possession buried deep in Bills territory.
Davis returned the kickoff 41 yards, but officials flagged Joe Andreessen for holding. Buffalo won 36–31. That flag still belongs in the discussion. Allen’s touchdowns naturally commanded attention afterward. Yet the special teams story deserves something sharper than either blanket praise or blanket blame. Buffalo produced excellent kicks, useful returns, and avoidable penalties that undermined its own work.
Those distinctions matter when evaluating a team with championship ambitions. The Bills do not need every return to become a touchdown. They need the yards their returners gain to survive the whistle. Against Houston, too much productive running ended with the offense walking backward.
The Field Position Problem
Twice, Allen started a touchdown possession at his own 4-yard line. His two 96-yard scoring drives included the winning march. The quarterback solved both problems, but that hardly makes the starting position desirable.
A field that long leaves little room for a bad exchange, a protection mistake, or a holding penalty. Before the offense can threaten the opponent, it must escape the shadow of its own goalposts. Allen can attack from there. Asking him to keep doing it increases the difficulty of an already demanding job.
Still, those long fields alone do not prove that Buffalo mishandled a return. Houston punter Kai Kroeger deserves credit for his placement. The stronger criticism of Buffalo Bills special teams comes from possessions where a flag demonstrably changed the starting point.
That responsibility belongs to Jeff Rodgers, whom Buffalo hired as special teams coordinator in January 2026. His evaluation must separate an opponent’s successful punt from a Bills blocker’s preventable foul. Those plays can produce similar field position while demanding entirely different responses.
The distinction keeps the coaching specific. A well-placed punt may leave Greg Dortch little space. An illegal block requires a correction regardless of where the kick lands.
Return Game Execution
Davis supplied the clearest example of wasted opportunity. His run offered Buffalo a chance to work near midfield before halftime. Andreessen’s holding call forced the offense to begin much farther away.
The third quarter brought another setback. Dortch gained eight yards on a punt return, but officials flagged Sam Franklin for an illegal blindside block. Buffalo again surrendered field position through its return blocking. These were specific failures by named players. Buffalo Bills special teams did not need a hypothetical example of a penalty ruining a return. The game supplied two.
The correction starts with how blockers engage and disengage. Once a defender wins position, grabbing him risks turning a modest gain into a substantial retreat. A forceful collision offers no benefit when the block itself breaks the rules.
Rodgers must preserve the aggression that makes Davis and Dortch dangerous while demanding cleaner support around them. Telling the returners simply to be more explosive misses the problem. On these plays, their teammates prevented Buffalo from keeping the ground they covered.
There is also a limit to the counterfactual. Nobody can assume either return would have ended at the same spot without the foul. The defensible conclusion is narrower: Buffalo committed penalties that worsened its actual starting position. For Buffalo Bills special teams, that gives the next practice a clear purpose. Finish legal blocks. Release lost ones. Let the return stand.
Coverage Discipline
Franklin’s afternoon also shows why one mistake should not become an entire player evaluation. Later in the third quarter, he downed Tommy Doman’s 63-yard punt at Houston’s 4-yard line. Buffalo’s defense then forced a punt, and Dortch’s ensuing return reached Houston territory.
That sequence gave Buffalo exactly what it wanted: distance for Houston to cover and a shorter field for Allen. Doman supplied the length. Franklin finished the play near the goal line. The defense protected the advantage instead of immediately giving it away.
Buffalo Bills special teams therefore offered a working example of the solution during the same game. The task is to reproduce that execution while eliminating the penalties elsewhere. Calling the entire operation broken would ignore those contributions. Doman flipped the field, Franklin completed the coverage assignment, and Dortch helped turn the next possession into an offensive opportunity. Those plays deserve space beside the costly flags.
Coverage discipline also means resisting the urge to make every tackle spectacular. The first defender must restrict the runner’s choices; the next must finish. Chasing a collision while abandoning the outside lane can undo the work of everyone pursuing from behind.
Houston exposed enough return-blocking trouble to justify scrutiny. Buffalo’s own punt coverage showed that scrutiny should lead to targeted changes, with successful assignments preserved and costly ones corrected.
Field Goal Operations
Bass gave Buffalo something steady amid the changing field position. He converted all three field goal attempts, connecting from 46, 34, and 33 yards. Each kick secured points after the offense stalled. That performance changes the argument. Buffalo Bills special teams needed cleaner blocking against Houston; its field goal unit delivered.
Across the field, Ka’imi Fairbairn demonstrated the danger of allowing Houston within striking distance. His 58-yard field goal finished a possession covering only 26 yards. Buffalo could force a relatively short drive and still surrender three points.
For Rodgers, the next step is to connect these pieces without flattening them into one grade. Keep the reliable kicking operation. Build on Doman’s ability to pin an opponent deep. Demand that the return blockers stop handing officials reasons to move the ball backward.
The review should measure where possessions actually begin after enforcement, alongside where returners finish their runs. That comparison makes the cost visible. It also prevents a clean kicking afternoon from concealing mistakes in a different part of the unit.
Buffalo Bills special teams already showed enough against Houston to make improvement feel attainable. The personnel produced useful plays; execution around the returns needed greater control. Allen can win from his own 4-yard line. Buffalo proved that twice. When Davis carries the football toward midfield, the Bills owe their quarterback the chance to start there.
READ MORE: Buffalo Bills vs Houston Texans: The Run Fits Edge
FAQ’s
What went wrong with Buffalo Bills special teams against Houston?
Joe Andreessen’s holding penalty and Sam Franklin’s illegal blindside block cost Buffalo valuable return yards. The kicking and punt coverage units also made important contributions.
Why didn’t Ray Davis’s 41-yard kickoff return give Buffalo good field position?
Officials flagged Joe Andreessen for holding. After enforcement, Buffalo started at its own 17-yard line instead of the 46.
Who coaches Buffalo Bills special teams in 2026?
Jeff Rodgers leads Buffalo’s special teams. The Bills hired him in January 2026.
How did Tyler Bass perform against the Texans?
Tyler Bass made all three field goal attempts, connecting from 46, 34, and 33 yards.
How did Tommy Doman help Buffalo against Houston?
Doman launched a 63-yard punt that Sam Franklin downed at Houston’s 4-yard line. Buffalo’s defense then forced a punt.
