Joel Nystrom gave the Carolina Hurricanes 38 regular season games during their championship campaign. When the NHL etched Carolina’s names onto the Stanley Cup, the defenseman was nowhere to be found.
Owner Tom Dundon appeared first. His wife and 5 children followed, placing 7 members of the Dundon family across the first 2 rows before the executives, coaches, staff members and players who built the championship team.
Nystrom did not qualify automatically under the NHL’s engraving rules. A player must appear in at least 41 regular season games or dress for 1 Stanley Cup Final game. His 38 appearances left him 3 games short. Carolina also reassigned him to the Chicago Wolves before the playoffs, removing his other route to automatic eligibility.
The controversy begins with what Carolina did next. The Hurricanes used only 53 of the permitted 55 spaces. Dundon did not run out of room. The organization left 2 places empty while excluding a player who spent almost half the season on its blue line.
Nystrom’s 38 Games Were Not Enough
Nystrom recorded 10 points during his 38 appearances. He was not a ceremonial call up or someone who briefly passed through the roster. Carolina used him across a substantial part of the schedule before sending him back to the American Hockey League ahead of the postseason.
The comparison with Nicolas Deslauriers makes the decision harder to understand.
Carolina acquired Deslauriers from the Philadelphia Flyers on March 6 for a conditional 2027 seventh round pick. General manager Eric Tulsky described him as a strong and physical forward who could add experience and toughness before the playoffs.
Deslauriers appeared in only 7 regular season games for Carolina. He also played once during the opening playoff round.
Those numbers did not meet the NHL’s automatic engraving requirements. Since his name appears on the Cup, the Hurricanes received league approval to include him as an exception.
That was an organizational choice. Leaving Nystrom off was another.
Their roles differed. Carolina acquired Deslauriers to provide physical depth for the postseason, while Nystrom finished his season in the minors. Still, the gap between 7 regular season appearances and 38 demands an explanation. The Hurricanes have not publicly provided one.
Two Vacant Spots Deepen Bobby Gorman’s Omission
The 2 vacant engraving slots lead directly to Bobby Gorman’s case. Carolina could have honored the Dundon family, included Deslauriers and still found space for both Nystrom and one of the franchise’s longest serving employees.
Instead, Gorman’s name was also left off the Cup.
Gorman joined the organization during its Hartford Whalers years and had worked within the franchise since 1993. His service covered more than 3 decades, including Carolina’s 2006 Stanley Cup championship, when his name earned a place on the trophy.
Equipment managers rarely receive public attention, but their work touches every part of an NHL season. They sharpen skates, repair damaged equipment, prepare locker rooms and pack gear for long road trips. Staff members often arrive before the players and remain at the arena long after the building empties.
Carolina previously described its equipment department preparing rooms hours before morning skates and unloading gear at 3 a.m. after arriving in another city. Gorman spent years carrying that workload. He remained connected to the organization in a reduced role during the championship season, but his name did not make the final list. Hurricanes coach Rod Brind’Amour made his feelings clear when Gorman stepped back, saying, “We lost Bobby, and I hate to see that.”
His omission widened the engraving debate. This was no longer only about a player who narrowly missed a league threshold. It became a question of how Carolina measured contribution when deciding who deserved permanent recognition.
Dundon Family Placement Keeps Questions Alive
Dundon, his wife Veruschka and their children Caden, Dax, Drew, Blake and Tagan occupy the trophy’s most prominent positions. No formal team roles have been publicly identified for the 6 family members listed after the owner. Their names appear before the general manager, coaching staff and players.
The family did not directly consume Nystrom’s final available place because Carolina still had 2 open positions. That distinction matters. It also makes the omissions of Nystrom and Gorman more difficult to explain.
Carolina could have honored the owner’s family and still submitted both men for consideration. The club instead stopped at 53 names.
The Hurricanes followed the process established by the NHL. Nystrom lacked automatic eligibility, management controlled its staff selections and the league approved the final engraving. There is no indication that Carolina violated a formal rule.
League rules, however, cannot explain the judgment behind the final list.
Nystrom gave Carolina 38 games. Deslauriers contributed 7 regular season appearances and 1 playoff game. Gorman served the franchise from 1993 and performed the daily work that kept generations of Hurricanes players ready for the ice.
Two spaces remained available.
Until Carolina explains why those positions stayed vacant, the omissions will remain as visible as the names carved into the Stanley Cup.
READ ALSO: Blackhawks Face A Brutal Early Test After Connor Bedard Shoulder Surgery
Tracking stats and settling debates. If there is a scoreboard, I am watching it.
