The NFL practice squad has a quiet cliff edge, and veteran safety Jalen Mills reached it on an October Saturday. Detroit’s secondary had already taken hits. Avonte Maddox and Thomas Harper were on injured reserve, while other defensive backs had dealt with injuries. On October 10, the Lions elevated Mills for a third consecutive week ahead of their game against Arizona.
That third call was perfectly legal. A fourth would require something more complicated. Detroit could no longer use another standard regular-season elevation on Mills without first signing him to the 53-man roster. Somebody else might have to lose his spot.
Inside an NFL personnel department, that’s the sort of decision that can consume an afternoon. Mills had already contributed defensive and special teams snaps. Detroit also had a bye approaching, with injured players potentially returning afterward. The Lions might not need him next week. They could desperately need him two Sundays later.
By October, managing the NFL practice squad becomes a series of increasingly uncomfortable choices. The decisions involve far more than finding replacements for injured starters. Every move carries a potential cost in roster flexibility, player development, or game-day depth. How do teams survive the current injury wave without burning through the depth they’ll need in December?
The 16-Man Safety Net That Gets Smaller Every Week
Every NFL team begins the season believing it has enough depth. Training camp produces a list of players who impressed coaches, survived final cuts, and earned practice squad contracts. Then the injuries start.
A starting left tackle develops a knee problem. The backup guard suddenly needs to play 60 snaps. Meanwhile, the third-string safety finds himself taking first-team repetitions because two defensive backs cannot practice. The 53-man roster starts looking awfully small.
Under the NFL’s 2026 roster rules, teams can carry 16 standard practice squad players. Up to six spots can go to players with unlimited accrued NFL seasons. That provision allows organizations to retain experienced veterans alongside developmental prospects.
There is also a possible 17th spot, but it comes with an important restriction. The additional position belongs exclusively to a qualifying international player under the league’s International Player Pathway rules. Teams cannot use that exemption to stash another domestic cornerback or offensive tackle during an injury crisis.
The NFL designed that additional spot to create opportunities for international athletes, not to increase general roster flexibility. That distinction matters once injuries hit several positions.
A club might need an experienced center, a backup linebacker, and another defensive back simultaneously. Keeping all three could mean releasing someone with developmental upside. At the time, potential means considerably less than availability.
Coaches cannot protect a quarterback with a prospect’s projected ceiling. They need somebody who recognizes the defensive front and knows which rusher to block. That’s where NFL practice squad management becomes a weekly exercise in deciding which risks a team can afford.
Three Elevations and the Problem Nobody Wants on Saturday
The most useful tool in the practice squad rulebook also comes with an expiration date. Teams can temporarily elevate two practice squad players for a game, expanding their active/inactive roster to as many as 55. Those players automatically return to the practice squad afterward without clearing waivers.
However, the standard elevation mechanism allows an individual player only three regular-season game elevations before another appearance requires an active-roster signing. Detroit’s Mills situation showed how quickly those opportunities disappear. Pittsburgh provided an even messier example.
The Steelers entered the 2026 season with defensive back Doneiko Slaughter on their practice squad. Pittsburgh elevated him for its first three games against Atlanta, New England, and Cincinnati. Once those opportunities ran out, the Steelers signed him to the 53-man roster ahead of their Week 4 matchup with Cleveland.
The arrangement lasted only briefly. Following the Browns game, Pittsburgh released Slaughter and brought him back to the practice squad. Then, on October 10, the team signed him to the active roster again before facing Indianapolis.
Slaughter’s role had centered on special teams, yet Pittsburgh repeatedly adjusted his roster status to keep him available. Those transactions illustrate an important distinction in NFL rules.
Teams can temporarily elevate eligible practice squad players without exposing them to waivers. However, moving a player back from the permanent active roster requires another transaction. If the club waives a player who remains subject to the waiver system, other organizations can claim him before he returns to the practice squad.
Pittsburgh successfully brought Slaughter back, but the process carried risk. For the player, the stakes extend beyond administrative paperwork. One week brings an active-roster contract and a chance to contribute on Sunday. Another brings uncertainty about whether the same locker room will still have a place for him.
The NFL practice squad gives general managers room to maneuver. It doesn’t guarantee they’ll retain every player they want. Each elevation, promotion, or release can change the options available when another injury hits.
Tuesday Afternoon Is When Teams Decide Whom They Can Lose
Sunday’s injuries dominate the headlines. Tuesday’s decisions often determine how teams respond. By then, the medical staff has completed another round of evaluations. Coaches have reviewed the film, and personnel executives have started identifying replacements.
One question sits near the top of the agenda: Which practice squad players absolutely cannot leave?
NFL rules allow teams to protect up to four practice squad players each week from being signed to another organization’s active roster during the protection period. Everyone else remains vulnerable.
An unprotected practice squad player can sign with another club’s active roster without first passing through waivers. The new team must generally keep him on its active roster for at least three weeks. That gives general managers something to worry about beyond their own injury reports.
Protecting a young pass rusher might make sense in September. However, if two interior offensive linemen go down in October, the backup center suddenly becomes a more valuable asset. The protection decision changes accordingly.
Detroit demonstrated the other side of this competition on September 22. The Lions signed safety Bishop Fitzgerald directly from Pittsburgh’s practice squad to their active roster while dealing with injuries in the secondary.
Detroit had placed Avonte Maddox on injured reserve and needed additional coverage depth. Fitzgerald offered another option at safety. Pittsburgh, meanwhile, lost a player from its developmental pipeline.
Organizations aren’t just protecting their own prospects. They’re constantly scanning rival practice squads for immediate upgrades. A backup who looks expendable on one depth chart could become an essential piece somewhere else.
The competition becomes particularly fierce when multiple clubs lose players at the same position. Cornerback injuries across several teams, for example, can suddenly increase demand for veterans who spent the summer fighting for roster spots.
Consequently, NFL practice squad decisions require personnel departments to think beyond their own injuries. They must anticipate which players other teams might target before the next protection deadline. A promising young defender can disappear from a developmental roster if another organization offers an immediate opportunity.
Baltimore’s Offensive Line Shows How Tight the Numbers Get
Nothing exposes a thin roster quite like offensive line injuries. A receiver can enter the game with five plays designed specifically for him. A reserve running back might handle a handful of carries. An offensive tackle faces a less forgiving assignment. The defensive end across from him doesn’t care how recently he joined the team.
On October 10, the Baltimore Ravens elevated offensive tackle Chuma Edoga and guard Kyle Hergel from their practice squad ahead of their matchup with Atlanta. Starting guard Andrew Vorhees had appeared on the injury report with a foot problem. He managed only two limited practices during the week.
Baltimore needed insurance. Edoga entered the matchup with 62 career NFL appearances and 25 starts. Hergel had already received an elevation for the previous game without playing.
Neither move guaranteed an offensive snap. Baltimore had to prepare for the possibility that another lineman would aggravate an injury, or that Vorhees might be unable to play. If a guard goes down midway through the second quarter, the coaching staff cannot wait for Monday’s transactions. Someone must enter the huddle immediately.
Edoga’s experience at tackle and guard made him particularly useful. Baltimore could cover more than one potential problem with the same reserve. The numbers become even tighter on game day.
NFL teams can dress 48 players if at least eight offensive linemen are active. Without eight, the maximum drops to 47. That extra game-day spot sounds generous until coaches begin deciding who deserves it.
Carrying additional line depth can force a team to leave another position dangerously thin. Keeping an extra defensive back might mean exposing the offensive line to another injury. The decision can come down to whether a club needs its ninth lineman more than a third-string safety who also serves as a core punt gunner.
Both players have legitimate jobs, but only one might dress. That is the uncomfortable arithmetic behind NFL practice squad elevations. Teams must prepare for injuries they cannot predict while working within roster limits they cannot ignore.
The calculation also reveals why coaches value versatility. A veteran lineman who can handle multiple positions gives the staff more options than a specialist capable of playing only one spot. The same applies to defensive backs who understand several coverage assignments.
During a midseason injury crisis, those extra responsibilities can be the difference between making the game-day roster and watching from the sideline. A player who knows multiple assignments can help coaches avoid another emergency transaction.
Washington’s October Moves Reveal the Full Roster Puzzle
Not every injury problem can be solved through temporary elevations. Sometimes a team needs a player on the active roster for more than one Sunday. Other times, a returning starter creates a new squeeze.
Washington experienced both situations on October 10. The Commanders activated defensive end Deatrich Wise Jr. from the Reserve/Physically Unable to Perform list and signed linebacker Austin Keys from the practice squad.
Meanwhile, safety Darren Hall and receiver Van Jefferson received temporary elevations. Cornerback Trey Amos and running back Jeremy McNichols had also been ruled out with injuries.
Four separate additions addressed different personnel concerns. Keys received an active-roster contract, while Hall and Jefferson could return to the practice squad after the game. Wise’s activation also had to fit within Washington’s 53-man roster limit.
It was the kind of weekend reshuffling that rarely attracts national attention but consumes hours inside a personnel department. One move creates an opening, another fills it, and a returning veteran can force an entirely new decision.
Injured reserve rules make those decisions even harder. Moving an injured starter to injured reserve opens an active-roster spot. However, a player placed on regular-season injured reserve must miss at least four games before becoming eligible to return.
That’s an expensive commitment when doctors expect someone to recover sooner. Imagine a starting slot receiver dealing with a high-ankle sprain. The medical staff believes he might return in two or three weeks, but his progress remains uncertain.
Keeping him on the active roster preserves that possibility. It also occupies a place another healthy player could use. On the other hand, placing him on injured reserve guarantees a longer absence.
A starting left tackle facing season-ending knee surgery presents a much clearer decision. The complication grows when a team has several players with injuries that fall between those extremes. General managers must also account for return-designation limits and the timing of potential activations.
One decision can create three more. A player returning from a reserve list might force a corresponding roster move. That move could expose a backup to waivers or push another player onto the NFL practice squad.
By Saturday afternoon, a staff might have spent the entire week rearranging its roster just to field the healthiest possible lineup. Each addition demands a corresponding calculation about who stays, who leaves, and which positions need emergency coverage.
The Human Cost Hiding Inside the Transaction Report
NFL transaction announcements don’t leave much room for emotion. Signed. Elevated. Released. Re-signed. Four words can describe an exhausting month in a player’s career. A practice squad player spends the week attending meetings, studying opponent tendencies, and running repetitions with teammates. He might finish Friday believing he’ll dress on Sunday. By Saturday, the team could elevate somebody else.
Worse, an unexpected activation might force the organization to release him altogether. The uncertainty reaches beyond playing time.
Practice squad compensation differs from active-roster pay. Under the NFL’s collective bargaining rules, a player receiving a standard elevation earns the applicable prorated active-roster minimum for that week. That can represent a meaningful financial difference.
However, the biggest opportunity often involves proving that a player belongs. Slaughter’s experience in Pittsburgh captured that tension. His place on the roster changed repeatedly even as he continued contributing on special teams.
For the Steelers, those transactions preserved flexibility. For the player, they repeatedly changed his immediate employment situation. The same pressure follows veterans. Mills had years of NFL experience before Detroit signed him to its practice squad. Yet the Lions still had to decide whether his contributions justified a permanent roster commitment. Past accomplishments might get someone into the building, but they don’t automatically guarantee a place on Sunday.
The emotional toll can be especially sharp for younger players who spent the summer fighting through training camp. A rookie might finally begin mastering the playbook, only to lose his spot because the team desperately needs another healthy offensive lineman.
For players living through the midseason injury crunch, an opportunity can arrive with almost no warning and disappear just as quickly. The NFL practice squad offers a path toward regular-season snaps, but it also places careers at the mercy of injuries, roster limits, and decisions made behind closed doors.
December Will Expose Every Shortcut Taken in October
October injuries create immediate problems. December reveals whether teams solved them properly. A general manager who burns through three elevations on a valuable backup might face a difficult choice when another starter goes down. An organization that releases a developmental player to address one emergency could discover that another club has already claimed him.
Meanwhile, a team that keeps too many injured contributors on its active roster might enter a critical game without enough reliable special teams depth. These choices rarely look dramatic when they happen.
A Tuesday protection decision won’t appear in the box score. Neither will the choice to retain a backup center instead of another defensive back. However, both decisions can influence a game weeks later.
The best NFL practice squad plans account for those possibilities before the depth chart starts collapsing. Personnel departments track injury timelines, evaluate potential replacements, and consider which players another club might target.
They also know when to stop protecting potential. A prospect who needs another year of development offers little immediate help when an offensive line loses two starters. On the other hand, sacrificing every promising young player to survive October leaves the roster thinner when the season reaches its most demanding stretch.
Detroit’s decision with Mills, Pittsburgh’s handling of Slaughter, and Baltimore’s offensive line reinforcements reveal different sides of the same challenge. All three organizations needed healthy contributors without surrendering more flexibility than necessary.
When the next injury arrives, the general manager may have only hours to choose between an experienced veteran, an untested prospect, and a player waiting on another team’s practice squad. The difference between those choices might not become obvious until a quarterback takes a hit or a defensive back misses an assignment.
That’s the reality of NFL practice squad management during the midseason injury crunch. Championship contenders spend the offseason assembling their best 53 players. By December, their seasons might depend on decisions they made about the players waiting just beyond that roster.
And when another starter limps toward the sideline, nobody in the personnel department cares much about preseason potential anymore. They need someone who can play. The question is whether they kept the right guy.
READ MORE: What separates successful NFL quarterback sneaks from short-yardage stops
FAQ’s
How many players can an NFL team have on its practice squad?
NFL teams can carry 16 standard practice squad players in 2026. A qualifying international player can fill an additional 17th spot.
How many times can an NFL practice squad player be elevated?
A player can receive three standard regular-season elevations. For another appearance, the team must first sign him to the active roster.
Can NFL teams sign players from another team’s practice squad?
Yes. Teams can sign eligible, unprotected practice squad players directly to their active roster and must generally keep them there for three weeks.
How many practice squad players can play in one NFL game?
Teams can temporarily elevate up to two players for a game, increasing the active/inactive roster from 53 to as many as 55.
Why do NFL teams use practice squad players during injury crises?
They provide familiar, ready-to-play replacements without requiring every injury to trigger a permanent roster signing.
