NFL kicker struggles announce themselves in a strange silence. The snap reaches the holder, the ball turns upright, and thousands of people track the same spinning piece of leather. Then it slides outside the post. You can usually see the damage before the score changes: the kicker stares at the turf, the head coach pulls his play sheet toward his chest, and players waiting for the kickoff unit hesitate as another supposedly automatic point disappears.
Through four weeks of the 2025 season, even established specialists had endured uneven starts. Harrison Butker converted 10 of 13 field goals and seven of nine extra points, according to NFL game logs. Chase McLaughlin went 9-for-12 on field goals and 8-for-9 on extra points over the same span. Those percentages tell only part of the story because a miss early on Sunday can dictate a decision two hours later.
A comfortable field-goal choice can turn into fourth-down roulette. A coach who trusted his kicker in September may suddenly reconsider where scoring territory actually starts. That is the hidden price of a bad kick: the NFL does not simply subtract a point. It rewrites the next decision.
The Death of the Automatic Point
For decades, an NFL touchdown effectively meant seven points. The extra point offered so little suspense that television crews could squeeze in replays while players lined up. In 2014, before the league changed the rule, kickers made 99.3% of extra-point attempts. Missing one bordered on freakish.
Then the NFL moved the line of scrimmage back to the 15-yard line for the 2015 season, turning the attempt into something resembling a 33-yard field goal. Through Week 4 that year, NFL data showed kickers converting just 283 of 300 attempts, or 94.3%. Seventeen extra points had already gone missing, while the entire 2014 season produced only eight misses. A ceremonial play had acquired teeth.
That shift still shapes modern football. The difference between 99.3% and roughly 94% sounds small on paper, but coaches experience those percentages in moments that decide games. Picture the sideline after a first-quarter touchdown: the offense celebrates, the crowd roars, and then the extra point hooks right. Instead of 7-0, the board reads 6-0.
Twenty minutes later, the opponent scores and takes a 7-6 lead. Another touchdown puts the first team ahead 12-7. Now the coach confronts a decision that would never have existed if the original kick had gone through: kick for 13, chase two and reach 14, or stay conventional and repair the damage later. That first miss has already survived three possessions, which is why NFL kicker struggles become dangerous long after the ball leaves the kicker’s foot.
Modern Range Has Raised the Standard Even Higher
There is another tension inside the position. Extra points became harder, yet field-goal range kept expanding. Brandon Aubrey showed how dramatically expectations have changed. Through four weeks in 2025, NFL game logs had him perfect on nine field-goal attempts and 11 extra points, and he had already drilled a 64-yarder against the Giants.
A kick from that distance once looked like desperation. Now, with the right specialist, coaches treat midfield differently. Cross the 50-yard line and the defense starts feeling pressure before the offense reaches traditional scoring territory. A third-down stop near the 45 may no longer end the threat because the kicker jogging from the sideline can still produce points.
That progress carries a brutal side effect. Fans increasingly judge a missed 42-yarder against a world in which kickers regularly threaten from 60. The mechanical margin has not grown with the expectation. A ball still needs a clean snap, the holder still has fractions of a second to place it, and the kicker still has to strike a sweet spot only inches wide. Coaches now expect 60-yard range, but the margin for error remains microscopic.
The Scoreboard Tax
A missed kick does not stay isolated for long. Imagine a team leading 13-7 because its kicker missed an extra point earlier. The opponent scores a touchdown late in the fourth quarter and makes the kick, turning the score to 14-13. A mistake from the first half has suddenly become the difference between chasing a winning field goal and merely needing one to tie.
Change the sequence slightly and the consequences grow. A team trails 21-20 after an earlier missed extra point, scores a touchdown and goes ahead 26-21. Instead of calmly kicking to make it 27-21, the coach may chase two for a full seven-point margin. The conversion fails, the opponent later scores and makes the extra point, and now the trailing offense needs three.
That is the tax: one failure creates pressure on decisions that have nothing to do with the original kick. When NFL kicker struggles change the available margins, coaches start compensating. Third-and-long can become more aggressive because the field-goal option no longer feels secure, while fourth-and-two suddenly becomes tempting.
A quarterback absorbs another pressure snap, and an offensive coordinator reaches deeper into his short-yardage menu. None of those consequences appear beside the kicker’s name in a box score. They still shape the afternoon.
McLaughlin Showed the Other Side of the Equation
Chase McLaughlin’s Week 4 performance against Philadelphia offered a useful counterexample. Tampa Bay entered halftime trailing 24-6, but McLaughlin had just crushed a 65-yard field goal as the second quarter expired. The Associated Press reported that the kick established the longest field goal made in an outdoor NFL stadium at the time.
More important than the record was what followed. Tampa Bay erupted for two touchdowns in the third quarter and cut Philadelphia’s advantage to 31-20. McLaughlin later added another field goal as the Buccaneers kept pushing, eventually losing 31-25. His 65-yarder had not merely decorated a box score; those three points remained valuable while Tampa Bay tried to erase a massive deficit.
That afternoon also showed why NFL kicker struggles cannot be judged through team results alone. McLaughlin made all three field-goal attempts and both extra points, yet the Buccaneers still lost. A kicker can do his job perfectly and leave without a win, while another can miss and watch his defense erase the mistake. Special teams influence games, but they do not own them. That distinction matters even more because a failed kick does not always mean the kicker actually broke the play.
Anatomy of a Miss
Television makes kicking look solitary. The camera centers the kicker, the graphic lists his percentage, and when the ball misses, his face fills the screen. Inside the operation, however, three jobs collide in roughly a second.
First comes the snap. A low ball forces the holder to reach downward and steals precious time, while a snap drifting toward his hip can pull the placement away from its designed spot. Next comes the hold, where the holder must catch the ball, rotate the laces away from the kicker and plant it at the proper angle. A slight tilt changes the strike, and laces facing the wrong direction can alter contact.
Protection completes the sequence. Interior linemen must survive an immediate surge while edge protectors preserve the launch point. One defender squeezing through the A-gap can turn clean mechanics into chaos before the kicker’s foot arrives. Pittsburgh encountered exactly that problem against Minnesota in Week 4 of 2025. The Steelers lined up for a routine 30-yard Chris Boswell field goal late in the second quarter with a 14-3 lead and a chance to stretch the margin to two touchdowns. Then Isaiah Rodgers burst through the protection and blocked the kick.
Minnesota used the possession that followed to drive for a field goal before halftime, turning what could have become a 17-3 Pittsburgh advantage into a 14-6 game. The stat sheet charges Boswell with a failed field-goal attempt, but the tape tells a richer story. Minnesota reached the football before Boswell could finish the operation, making the failed attempt a unit problem rather than simply a kicking mistake.
That distinction matters whenever teams evaluate NFL kicker struggles. A ball pulled left from clean protection demands one diagnosis, while a low snap demands another. An interior rusher arriving untouched points somewhere else entirely. Weather complicates the picture further. Imagine a November afternoon at Soldier Field, where flags above the uprights snap one direction while wind swirls lower inside the stadium bowl. Rain slicks the turf around the holder’s spot, and the plant foot searches for grip. The official statistics record only make or miss, but football people have to see everything underneath it.
The Evaluation Trap
Four games can make a kicker look broken, but four games can also lie. Kickers work with tiny samples compared with almost every other major position. A quarterback might throw 35 passes in one afternoon, while a kicker could attempt only two field goals. One block changes his percentage dramatically, and two misses can turn a stable month into what looks like a crisis.
Butker’s opening four games in 2025 illustrate that tension. He made 10 of 13 field goals, but those numbers came from only 13 attempts. One additional make would have shifted his percentage noticeably, and two more would have transformed the entire conversation. That does not mean early misses should be ignored, because coaches cannot wait forever.
Trust at kicker works differently from trust at most positions because the decision arrives before the player enters the field. A head coach must decide whether he believes the attempt will succeed before sending the unit out. Lose that belief and the entire fourth-down chart changes.
A fourth-and-three from the 31-yard line should present one set of options with a trusted kicker. The same situation feels completely different when the coach has watched two kicks sail wide. Suddenly, the offense stays out, the quarterback gets another snap, and the defense prepares for a short field if the conversion fails. That is how NFL kicker struggles spread beyond special teams.
Reliability Buys Something Statistics Rarely Capture
A dependable kicker gives a head coach freedom. Near the edge of field-goal range, the offensive coordinator does not need to manufacture another five yards at any cost. On third down, the quarterback can throw the ball away rather than force it through bracket coverage. Field position becomes less claustrophobic because three points still feel available.
A powerful leg stretches that comfort zone even farther. With someone such as Aubrey available, the definition of scoring range changes before the drive even reaches the opponent’s 40. Reliability creates options, while doubt removes them.
Come December, early September misfires fade from memory until playoff margins strip away the safety net. A one-point loss counts the same in the standings whether it came from a failed goal-line stand, a red-zone interception or an extra point that drifted outside the upright. Coaches have to decide which misses signal trouble and which belong to normal variance. Replace the kicker too quickly and a team may dump a proven specialist during a temporary slump. Wait too long and those missing points can accumulate. There is no clean formula, which is why the best way to understand NFL kicker struggles is to watch what happens after the miss.
Notice whether the coach passes up a 48-yard attempt and leaves the offense on the field. Watch the two-point chart after an early PAT goes wide. Track where the opponent takes possession after a long attempt misses. That is where the real cost appears.
Moving back the extra point injected genuine uncertainty into routine touchdowns, while stronger legs transformed 60-yard attempts from emergency heaves into realistic weapons. Those developments pulled the position in opposite directions. Teams demand greater range than ever, yet they also demand near perfection.
Between those expectations sits a specialist working through a snap, hold and swing that can unravel in less than two seconds. The next miss will look simple on television: the camera follows the ball toward the upright, the kicker turns away, and the crowd groans. Then the game bends around it.
Fourth down looks different. A two-point conversion moves onto the call sheet. Field position carries more weight. That is the real trap: in today’s NFL, a missed extra point rarely stops at minus-one. The ball may land behind the goalpost, but its consequences can linger until the final snap.
READ MORE: NFL Heavy Personnel Turns 12 and 13 Sets Into Passing Weapons
FAQs
Why did the NFL move the extra point back?
The NFL moved extra-point attempts to the 15-yard line in 2015 to make the play less automatic. Conversion rates dropped noticeably afterward.
How long is an NFL extra point?
An NFL extra point works out to roughly a 33-yard kick because the line of scrimmage sits at the 15-yard line.
How can a missed extra point change NFL strategy?
A miss can change later two-point decisions, fourth-down calls and field-goal choices. Coaches may spend the rest of the game trying to recover that point.
How far can modern NFL kickers make field goals?
Elite kickers now threaten from beyond 60 yards. Brandon Aubrey made a 64-yard field goal against the Giants during the 2025 season.
Is every missed field goal the kicker’s fault?
No. A bad snap, poor hold or protection breakdown can ruin an attempt before the kicker has a clean chance to strike the ball.
